In the british popular science magazine focus, astronomer and author bill napier answers the question, what is the most important book of all time. Church politics and the genocide in rwanda 167 catholic brothers, catechists, and other church employees, and the fact that death squads attended mass before going out to kill or that killers paused during the massacres to pray at the altar3 suggests that people felt their work was consistent with church teachings. No direct matches for your keyword exist in the king james bible. Some have suggested that this is a command to commit genocide, although we dispute this in our book and attempt to bring clarity to this and. Ham wrote in the foreword, many people today buy into the assertion that the bible is full of contradictions, but they havent bothered to look into the claim for themselves. Im particularly disturbed by the accounts of divinely authorized genocide and holy war recorded in numbers, deuteronomy, and joshua. As formulated, a christian who believes the bible is gods word must deny that genocide is wrong. Why did god condone such terrible violence in the old. Why did god command the extermination genocide of the. Why the unlimited 3rd world immigration into the united states and europe.
Genocide and the old testament evidence for christianity. Besides, the need for such a book to establish national credibility was much more crucial for ezras community than for the hasmonean leaders in the second century b. The bible describes small children as not knowing right from wrong, and in. Click the search button below to search the entire website including all scripture translations, comments, commentary, bible dictionary, articles, and other pages. But as reasonable and noble as that desire may be, the bible is simply not that kind of book. For example, the book of judges includes the judge deborah, who was honored, as well as two of the most egregious examples in the bible of violence against women. The holy bible is called the good book or the not so good book, but its actually not a book. Who printed the bibles and built all of the churches. Doesnt the bible condone slavery, sexism, and genocide. Apr 18, 2012 terrible parts of the bible part 1 genocide most my life, i, like most people assumed the bible was a book about love, peace, tolerance and rules for a good life.
And we took all his cities at that timethere was not a city that we did not take from themsixty cities, the whole region of argob, the kingdom of og in bashan. In it he proposed the international regulation of genocidethe practice of extermination of nations and ethnic groups. The only reason the israelites were right to destroy cities in the ot is because they received a clear, direct command from god to do so. White genocide is mentioned in bible end time prophecy why they hate whites the bible has the answer. In the hebrew bible the book of esther is placed in the third main part, that is the writings hebr. To say that the god of the bible is a fiction doesnt help answer that at all, and to say that the incidents. Genocide in the bible quotes quotes tagged as genocideinthebible showing 14 of 4 i have argued elsewhere fighting words. Some of the stories are dull and boring, others are somewhat intriguing. The hebrew bible and the new testament contain narratives, poetry, and instruction describing.
Even a casual reader of the bible notices that between the alleged divine endorsement of genocide in the conquest of canaan and jesuss call for. Oct 28, 2017 white genocide is mentioned in bible end time prophecy why they hate whites the bible has the answer. Terrible parts of the bible part 1 genocide most my life, i, like most people assumed the bible was a book about love, peace, tolerance and rules for a good life. Esther is read during the purim feast on 14th and 15th adar februarymarch. The violence of scripture and millions of other books are available for amazon. The origins of religious violence 2005 that we need to treat ethics in biblical texts just as we treat ethics in any other works of ancient literature. The book of joshua is the sixth book in the hebrew bible and the christian old testament, and. This involvement in canaanite religions is already evident in the book of judges. Feb 27, 2016 watch our overview video on the book of joshua, which breaks down the literary design of the book and its flow of thought.
I could have added a fourth possibility to the three above. Esther is, among the generality of jews, the best known of all the books of the bible p. Whenever its teachings on repentance and faith to god and on loving our neighbour as ourselves have been followed, down the ages, the bible has. Corrected and explained kindle edition by gastrich, jason. Listen to this description in the five megilloth, a jewish commentary published by the soncino press. More recently, israeli education minister naftali bennett. Shalom richard, before i answer to the question in this thread is the genocide in the bible justified. Terrible parts of the bible part 1 genocide whistling in. The book belongs to the socalled five scrolls hebr. He commanded israel to cleanse canaan of its immoral, idolworshiping nations after the exodus, and in 1 samuel 15 he instructed them to destroy amalek completely, man and women, child and infant, oxen and sheep, camel and donkey. That breaks israels covenant not to mention hurts gods feelings. It describes the apocalypse, the last judgment of all the nations and. Demolishing supposed bible contradictions volume 1.
Ravi zacharias international ministries 54,795 views. Dr paul coulter has a background in medicine, and also holds degrees in theology and genetics. All what i have read are from christians, which cannot convince any reader, just because they dont have the right understanding. Christian struggles with biblical accounts of genocide and. In the book of joshua god commands israel to slaughter the canaanites in order to occupy the promised land. Did god really command genocide, exposes the special pleading, cherrypicking and blatant truthtwisting employed in many arguments used by atheists and skeptics. Genocide, evolution and the bible focus magazines answer to the question. If you rely on the bible as a book of truth, you have to defend the slaughter of innocent noncombatants without mercy at gods order. Instead, the old testament in particular is a record of dispute containing conflicting visions of what gods will looks like. Now he needs to pick a new queen and eventually manages to select esthera comely, young secretly jewish woman who is a part of his harem.
Jun 07, 2009 the god of the bible is often charged with gross immorality, especially for ordering entire nations to be destroyed in the old testament. Why did god command the extermination genocide of the canaanites, women and children included. This kind of biblical justification of genocidal violence against the native peoples of north america continued. In his bestselling book the god delusion, atheist richard dawkins refers to the god of the old testament as a vindictive, bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser. More than one genocidal movements have pointed back to this book to justify the horrible things they. To be honest, the bible is still one of your best sources for soap opera drama, rape and sex and violence, and genocide. As we saw in the previous posts on midian, amalek, and the canaanites, the individuals and families who follow yhwh and become part of israel are on one extreme of a spectrum the caleb end, while those who attack israel are located on the other extreme. Watch our overview video on the book of joshua, which breaks down the. And we took all his cities at that time, and utterly destroyed the men, and the women, and the little ones, of every city, we l. See introduction to 1 chronicles for outline and other introductory information.
Genocide is a deliberate, coordinated plan to destroy a group of people, usually members of a certain national, ethnic or religious group. These violent stories are often passed over altogether or explained away as cultural remnants of the time when the stories were transmitted and written down. To say that the god of the bible is a fiction doesnt help answer that at all, and to say that the incidents under. Why is it that people say the ancient sumerian tablets are similar to the book of genesis. Israel continues to conquer canaan after the death of joshua, but fails to completely drive out the canaanites as god commanded.
And we took all his cities at that time, and utterly destroyed the men, and the women, and the little ones, of every city, we left none to remain. When the israelites captured jericho, the bible says that they utterly destroyed all that was in the city, both man and woman, young and old, ox and sheep and donkey, with the edge of the sword joshua 6. The story behind the creature from jekyll island, the anti. The creature from jekyll island is marketed as the most important book on world affairs you will ever read. The book of esther begins with the queen of king ahasuerusvashtisnubbing the kings request to meet with her. Terrible parts of the bible part 1 genocide whistling. The fact that god commanded the killing of entire nations in the old testament has been the subject of harsh criticism from opponents of christianity for some time. Esther with book summary versebyverse bible commentary. Are the stories of genocide in the bible actually madeup. In the book of joshua god commands israel to slaughter the.
The story behind the creature from jekyll island, the. Studies in hebrew narrative and poetry 2000, is a model of close literary and theological exegesis. Some might say that for that reason we shouldnt have any confidence in any of the bible. I will punish the amalekites for what they did to israel when they waylaid them as they came up from egypt. As we saw in the previous posts on midian, amalek, and the canaanites, the individuals and families who follow yhwh and become part of israel are on one extreme of a spectrum the caleb end, while those who attack israel are. The discussion in the introduction to the book of joshua in the. The way we answer it will both reflect and inform our understanding of justice and mercy. Genocide is a term used to describe violence against members of a national, ethnic, racial or religious group with the intent to destroy the entire group. There is one question which comes up repeatedly, both as i travel and teach. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Why did god condone such terrible violence in the old testament. Jan 01, 2011 rethinking genocide in the bible paperback january 1, 2011 by douglas s. Book of judges summary israel continues to conquer canaan after the death of joshua, but fails to completely drive out the canaanites as god commanded. Often the mass killing of the canaanites is described as genocide or a. This summary of the book of 2 chronicles provides information about the title, authors, date of writing, chronology, theme, theology, outline, a brief overview, and the chapters of the book of 2 chronicles. Yet it is worth knowing that these unseemly accounts still exist in the bible, because some tend to treat this book as a homogeneous document that. Genocide is never part of our specific mission, and the times in church history when this has been forgotten are tragic and wrong. The question is whether old testament violence is justifiable and condoned by god. It is interesting that many of those who claim the bible is not a historical book and its historical narratives cannot be trusted are quick to accept the historical nature of the statements in the old testament regarding the israelites destroying the inhabitants of the land of canaan.
The term genocide did not exist prior to 1944, but examples of its occurrence, such as the armenian genocide of. It describes the apocalypse, the last judgment of all the nations and people by god, which includes plagues, war, and economic collapse. The canaanite destruction is the major ethical problem in the old testament. The book of esther 6 powerful life lessons from the bible. Some other books of the gospels also use apocalyptic language and forms. Skeptics claim that a person who believes both that god exists and that the bible is gods authoritative word is rationally committed to four claims. As we walk through joshua at orlando grace church, the elephant in the room is gods commanding the deaths of entire groups of canaanite people. Genocide, murder or any killing that is not necessary to defend another persons life is not justified. However, copan and flannagan do far more than offer an apologetic on why their arguments fail. God alone has the right to take human life in cases other than defense. Some have suggested that this is a command to commit genocide, although we dispute this in our book and attempt to bring clarity to this and related questions. What the bible does infallibly and inerrantly is point us to jesus, just. It was always assumed that if more people took a page out of the bible the world would be a better place.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the skeptics annotated bible. The joshua delusion rethinking genocide in the bible. In joshua, after moses death, joshua leads israel and they settle in the. At the height of holocaust, and with that in mind, lemkin wrote his 1944 book on, axis rule in occupied europe, which was the first public articulation of the concept. The bible is indeed the most important book of all time, but not for the reason that bill suggests. In america we talk about the separation of church and state. Why was it necessary to remove the canaanites from the land. Sefer yehoshua is the sixth book in the hebrew bible and the christian old testament, and is the first book of the deuteronomistic history, the story of israel from the conquest of canaan to the babylonian exile. Jan 02, 2020 that there was violence in the old testament is indisputable. Genocide in the old testament rational christianity.
What the bible says about genocide the annotated bible. Search popularity is shown in blue using the scale below. They were divided by the translators of the septuagint and were entitled things left behind i. Apr, 2017 the story behind the creature from jekyll island, the antifed conspiracy theory bible rabbit hole the fed was secretly created to enact vicious cycles of genocide. Was that just the old testament god who demanded that. After leaving his medical career, he worked for six years for a church in belfast and now lectures full time for belfast bible college. Herbert did ancient israel commit genocide against the canaanites. It is interesting that many of those who claim the bible is not a historical book and its historical narratives cannot be trusted are quick to accept the historical nature of the statements in the old testament regarding the israelites destroying the inhabitants of the land of canaan which they claim to be an example of genocide. Questioning genocide and slavery in the bible huffpost. If there is a holy seed then there needs to be an unholy seed. Did you know that white genocide is mentioned in bible end times prophecy. Those that remain behind turn israel toward the worship of their idol gods not those gods.
Jun 15, 2018 bengurions attachment to the bible was shared by almost every zionist leader of his generation and the next. He has spent the bulk of his career wrestling with the book of joshua, arguably the bible s most troubling book, with its account of the conquest of the land. Bengurions attachment to the bible was shared by almost every zionist leader of his generation and the next. The book of revelation is full of imagery of war, genocide, and destruction. The book of 2 chronicles was originally one book with 1 chronicles in the hebrew text. Bible verses related to genocide from the king james version kjv by relevance sort by book order 1 samuel 15. But be certain, just genocide will indeed occur again on the last day, when all those who do not know christ and who disobey the glorious gospel will be punished with everlasting destruction 2 thessalonians 1. That there was violence in the old testament is indisputable. The author of the book of esther is unknown, though some attribute the work to mordecai. The individual reigns of the descendants of david are featured, from the time of solomon until the fall of jerusalem under zedekiah in 586 b. The only way to explain away the problem of the old testament mass killings is to. This supershort chapter ends the book, stating that king ahasuerus continued to have great power, exacting tribute money from many different lands. The bible is gods message to man on how to have peace with god and with our fellow man.
If anyone wants to know more about the story of esther and mordecai, and if it really happened, the book says they should read the official annals of persia and media where its all recorded. In the present paper, i argue that the genocide passages in the old testament provide us with a strong prima facie reason to reject biblical inerrancythat in the absence of better reasons for thinking that the bible is inerrant, a christian should conclude that god did not in fact command genocide. How could god command genocide in the old testament. Ethnic cleansing and genocide refer to destruction of a people due to their ethnicity, and therefore this would be an inappropriate category for the destruction of the canaanites. Naturally, being a rather unstable fellow, ahasuerus firesslashdivorces her. Moshe dayan, the military hero of the 1967 six day war, wrote a book entitled living with the bible 1978 in which he justified the annexation of new territory by the bible. What are some of the primary arguments youre addressing in did god really command genocide. See 1 chronicles for more info on the introduction page there. No, god didnt command genocide in the old testament. That doesnt address the question satisfactorily, though, since the question is whether god as he is revealed in the bible is guilty of the genocide charge.
214 44 223 1506 221 510 504 1372 739 619 601 182 1063 1040 207 958 1282 159 1469 780 173 274 633 234 938 1084 64 474 478 515 1291 359